Synopsis Of Reviews Of "Hitler's Private Library" by Timothy Ryback
The completereview.com has posted an excellent synopsis of reviews of the book "Hitler's Private Library". There are many kinds of book collectors - famous, infamous and annonymous. Much as many of us may hate to claim him among the group of book collectors, he did indeed collect books. His purpose and what use he put to the volumes he collected are debatable, Some feel he sought out books that went along with his preconceived ideas - as some book collectors may do. The following reviewers had the this to say:
From the Reviews:
"The author neatly weaves together Hitler’s political career with his book-collecting habits, tracing the well-thumbed volumes that Hitler consulted during the writing of Mein Kampf. Mr Ryback’s knowledge of German literature and the politics of the Nazi era makes him well placed to follow clues and draw inferences, both from the time and place of acquisition and from the marginalia that can be found in the books." - The Economist
"This is no substitute to such monuments as, say, Ian Kershaw’s two-tome biography. But it serves as a companion to more traditional studies -- and deepens our understanding of Hitler’s personality." - Bertrand Benoit, Financial Times
"Thanks to his imaginative research -- and his willingness to investigate a very creepy subject -- we come closer to one of the most elusive men ever to shape world history. (...) His effort is worthwhile: one finishes this short, packed book with a firmer take on the sort of intellectual -- or pseudo-intellectual -- who persuaded the best-educated nation in Europe to make war on civilization and try to exterminate the Jews. But deep insights remain elusive." - Anthony Grafton, The New Republic
"What distinguishes the slim, elegantly written, meticulously researched, fascinating volume by Timothy Ryback, Hitler's Private Library, is his careful analysis of a small, selected number of works that he associates with formative episodes in Hitler's life. By evaluating the passages that Hitler has underlined, or added marginalia to, Mr. Ryback seeks to extract and elucidate what about the books was important to the man, and moreover what "occupied Hitler in his more private hours, often at pivotal moments in his career." " - Ian Kershaw, The New York Sun
"Still, Ryback has provided a tantalizing glimpse into Hitler’s creepy little self-improvement program. While being a bookworm may not be a precondition for becoming a mass murderer, it’s certainly no impediment." - Jacob Heilbrun, The New York Times Book Review
"Ryback relies heavily on Walter Benjamin’s idea of the private library as a map of its owner’s character, but Hitler’s reading yields few new insights, and some of what Ryback dredges up is merely peculiar" - The New Yorker
"Timothy Ryback has tried to glean some insight into the emotional life, hatreds and enthusiasms of the Nazi leader. There are few surprises. Rather than yield with humility to writers and their books, Hitler used them merely to bolster his preconceptions. (...) Hitler's Private Library, the fruit of eight years' research, provides a warning against the dangers of blind adherence to ideology and the damage that a deal of selective reading can do." - Ian Thomson, Sunday Times
"Ryback has made an original and interesting contribution to the study of this monster, not least by showing that, in some respects, he was just like many of the rest of us." - Simon Heffer, The Telegraph
"While Hitler's Private Library is crisply written and covers the dictator's reading life from World War I to his suicide in 1945, Ryback could have dug a little deeper. (...) While thoroughly engrossing, like virtually all books about the Nazi dictator, Hitler's Private Library does sometimes leave a reader slightly annoyed or puzzled. Details are occasionally wrong or at least fuzzy and in need of clarification. (...) These gripes aside, Hitler's Private Library is still fascinating -- and unnerving." - Michael Dirda,
The Washington Post
"Ryback knows the history of this period exceptionally well, and has a good eye for spotting and highlighting revealing vignettes; the links he establishes between the books and the life invariably make for absorbing reading. (...) Ryback deserves praise for his investigative labors and, especially in our increasingly virtual and digitalized age, for recognizing what the physical nature of books may reveal about their owners. He also deserves a reader’s gratitude for being a graceful and interesting writer. Nevertheless, Ryback’s approach is seriously flawed." - Michael McDonald,
Weekly Standard
"Eine faszinierende Studie, die interessante, aber nicht überraschend neue Einblicke in die Persönlichkeit Hitlers bietet." - Marion Lühe, Die Welt
"Rybacks Buch fügt dem Hitler-Bild keine grundlegend neuen Erkenntnisse, wohl aber unbekannte Facetten hinzu." - Volker Ullrich, Die Zeit
The previous reviews are followed up by: The complete review's Review: This review is insightful and extremely well written - well worth visiting the site for a read...
Link to this page
